0What this model is这个模型是什么
A process model of soil organic carbon for New Zealand land uses. Click a block on KiwiMap, take the land use and fertiliser regime from KiwiFert, and it returns carbon stocks through time, the final profile, and a complete carbon mass balance — each with an uncertainty band rather than a single misleading line.
这是一个面向新西兰各类土地利用的土壤有机碳过程模型。在 KiwiMap 上点选一个地块,从 KiwiFert 取用土地利用和施肥制度,它就会给出碳储量随时间的变化、最终的剖面,以及一份完整的碳质量平衡 — 每一项都带有不确定性区间,而不是一条容易误导人的单线。
Most soil carbon tools ask for numbers nobody has: decay constants, specific surface area, microbial carbon use efficiency. This one asks instead for what a farm, a consultant or a research group is likely to know — a point on a map, a soil order, a crop, a stocking policy, a fertiliser programme — and fills the rest from libraries of published New Zealand values. Every one of those values is a plain JavaScript file you can open, read and overwrite.
大多数土壤碳工具要求输入谁也没有的数字:分解常数、比表面积、微生物碳利用效率。这个模型改为询问农场、顾问或研究团队大概率已经知道的东西 — 地图上的一个点、一个土纲、一种作物、一套放牧方案、一份施肥方案 — 其余部分则从已发表的新西兰数值库中补齐。所有这些数值都存放在普通的 JavaScript 文件里,你可以打开、阅读并改写。
What the model does模型做什么
Soil carbon is split into pools that behave differently, because that is the difference between a change that lasts and one that does not:
土壤碳被划分为行为各不相同的几个库,因为能持久的变化与不能持久的变化之间的区别正在于此:
- Particulate organic matter — recognisable plant fragments, not protected by anything. It turns over in years, responds quickly to a change in management, and is just as quickly lost again.
- Mineral-associated organic matter — carbon sorbed onto clay and oxide surfaces, turning over in decades to centuries. This is the pool worth building, and it saturates: a soil already near its capacity cannot store much more, whatever you add.
- Microbial biomass — small, but every gram of carbon that becomes mineral-associated passes through it first. It moves years before the slow pools do, which makes it the early indicator.
- Inert pyrogenic carbon — char, effectively permanent, which is why a single biochar application behaves so differently from an annual compost application.
- 颗粒有机质 — 仍可辨认的植物碎片,不受任何保护。它以年为尺度周转,对管理方式的改变反应迅速,也同样迅速地再次损失。
- 矿物结合有机质 — 吸附在黏粒和氧化物表面的碳,以数十年到数百年为尺度周转。这才是值得积累的库,而且它会饱和:一个已接近容量的土壤,无论你添加什么,都存不下多少了。
- 微生物生物量 — 量很小,但每一克最终成为矿物结合态的碳都要先经过它。它比慢库早好几年发生变化,因此是早期指标。
- 惰性热解碳 — 炭,实际上是永久性的;这就是为什么施用一次生物炭与每年施用堆肥的表现截然不同。
Carbon leaves as carbon dioxide, as methane where the soil goes anaerobic, as dissolved organic carbon draining below the root zone, and in whatever is harvested or eaten. All of it is tracked and reported, so the Net Ecosystem Carbon Balance is an accounting result rather than an assertion.
碳以二氧化碳的形式离开;在土壤转为厌氧之处,以甲烷的形式离开;以溶解性有机碳的形式随排水流到根区以下;还随被收获或被采食的部分离开。所有这些都被追踪并报告,因此净生态系统碳平衡(Net Ecosystem Carbon Balance)是一个核算结果,而不是一个断言。
Why the fertiliser is an input and not an afterthought为什么肥料是一项输入,而不是事后补充
Soil carbon is oxidised by microorganisms, and two of the strongest controls on what those organisms manage to oxidise are the nitrogen supply and the pH. Both are set by what is spread on the block. Nitrogen relieves the immobilisation demand that holds back decomposition of nitrogen-poor residue while simultaneously repressing the oxidative enzymes that attack humified carbon; lime moves the pH towards the microbial optimum, which is the oldest observation in the subject. A soil carbon model that does not know the fertiliser and liming programme is guessing at some of its largest terms. Section 10 sets out exactly what the model does with a regime, and the Fertiliser tab can take one straight from KiwiFert.
土壤碳由微生物氧化,而决定这些微生物能氧化多少的两个最强的控制因素是氮供应和 pH。两者都由施到地块上的东西决定。氮解除了抑制贫氮残体分解的固持需求,同时又抑制攻击腐殖化碳的氧化酶;石灰把 pH 推向微生物的最适值,这是该领域最古老的观察。一个不了解施肥和施石灰方案的土壤碳模型,等于是在猜测其中几个最大的项。第 10 节具体说明了模型如何处理一套施肥制度,而“肥料与石灰”选项卡可以直接从 KiwiFert 取用一套。
Where the site comes from地点信息从哪里来
The Site tab is a live KiwiMap. Click a block and the model reads the soil order, the New Zealand Soil Classification subgroup, the topsoil carbon with its mapped minimum and maximum, pH, cation exchange capacity, drainage, texture, depth, land cover, land use and the seasonal climate at that point, then writes them into the ordinary editable panels. Nothing is locked: a measurement from the block itself always outranks a national raster, and typing over an imported value is the expected thing to do rather than a workaround.
“地点与土地利用”选项卡是一个实时的 KiwiMap。点选一个地块,模型就会读取该点的土纲、新西兰土壤分类亚类、表土碳及其制图最小值和最大值、pH、阳离子交换量、排水性、质地、深度、土地覆盖、土地利用和季节气候,然后把它们写入普通的可编辑面板。没有任何东西是锁定的:来自地块本身的测量值总是优先于全国栅格数据,而直接改写导入的数值是预期的做法,并不是变通手段。
The monthly climate library is not replaced by any of that. KiwiMap carries seasonal mean temperatures but neither monthly rainfall nor evapotranspiration, so importing a point keeps the nearest station's monthly series from data/climate-nz.js and shifts its temperatures to match the mapped seasonal means. Rainfall and PET stay exactly as the station recorded them.
以上这些都不会取代逐月气候库。KiwiMap 提供季节平均气温,但既没有逐月降雨量,也没有蒸散,因此导入一个点时,会保留 data/climate-nz.js 中最近站点的逐月序列,并平移其气温以匹配制图的季节平均值。降雨量和 PET 完全保持站点的记录值。
What it is not它不是什么
It is a research and teaching tool. It is not a carbon accounting standard, it is not calibrated to any one site, and it should not be used to make a claim about a particular paddock without local measurements. The single most influential number in it — the decay constant for mineral-associated carbon — is uncertain by a factor of about five, which is why the model reports a band and why the band is often wide enough to include no change at all. That is not a defect in the model. It is the state of the knowledge.
它是一个研究和教学工具。它不是碳核算标准,没有针对任何一个地点做过校准,在没有当地测量值的情况下,不应被用来对某一块围场下结论。其中影响最大的单个数字 — 矿物结合碳的分解常数 — 的不确定性约为五倍,这就是为什么模型报告的是一个区间,也是为什么这个区间往往宽到连“毫无变化”都包含在内。这不是模型的缺陷,而是现有认识的现状。
Built to last为长期可用而构建
Plain HTML, three shared stylesheets and a handful of JavaScript files. No framework, no build step, no analytics, no external requests. Download the folder, open index.html, and the model works — on a plane, on a farm with no signal, or in ten years when whatever is fashionable now has been forgotten. Only the two panels that reach out to KiwiMap and KiwiFert need a local server, and each says so plainly when it does not have one; everything else keeps working without them.
纯 HTML、三个共享样式表和少量 JavaScript 文件。没有框架,没有构建步骤,没有统计分析,没有外部请求。下载这个文件夹,打开 index.html,模型就能运行 — 在飞机上、在没有信号的农场里,或者十年后当下流行的东西都已被遗忘之时。只有连接 KiwiMap 和 KiwiFert 的两个面板需要本地服务器,没有服务器时它们会直接说明;其余一切不依赖它们照常工作。
1Structure结构
The model runs a monthly timestep over a user-set number of years. The profile is divided into horizons — by default an A, a B and a C — and each horizon carries five carbon pools. Above them sit two whole-profile surface pools.
模型以月为时间步长,运行用户设定的年数。剖面被划分为若干土层 — 默认是 A 层、B 层和 C 层 — 每个土层含有五个碳库。在它们之上是两个属于整个剖面的地表库。
| Pool | What it is | Typical turnover |
|---|---|---|
| Litter (O horizon) | Plant residue and dung lying on the surface | Months to a few years |
| Mulch | Surface-applied compost, wood chip, straw | Depends on the material |
| POM | Particulate organic matter: plant fragments in the soil, not protected | Years |
| POMo | The particulate carbon already present when the run starts. It receives no new input and only decays | Years, or millennia in a peat |
| MAOM | Mineral-associated organic matter, sorbed to clay and oxide surfaces | Decades to centuries |
| MBC | Living microbial biomass | Weeks to months |
| IOM | Inert pyrogenic carbon: char and condensed aromatics | Centuries to millennia |
| 库 | 是什么 | 典型周转时间 |
|---|---|---|
| 凋落物(O 层) | 堆积在地表的植物残体和粪 | 数月至数年 |
| 覆盖物 | 施于地表的堆肥、木屑、秸秆 | 取决于材料 |
| POM | 颗粒有机质:土壤中未受保护的植物碎片 | 数年 |
| POMo | 运行开始时已存在的颗粒态碳。它不接受新的输入,只会分解 | 数年;在泥炭中可达数千年 |
| MAOM | 矿物结合有机质,吸附在黏粒和氧化物表面 | 数十年至数百年 |
| MBC | 活的微生物生物量 | 数周至数月 |
| IOM | 惰性热解碳:炭和缩合芳香物质 | 数百年至数千年 |
Why POM and POMo are separate为什么 POM 和 POMo 要分开
A single particulate pool forces this season's root litter and a soil's inherited organic matter to share one decay constant. In a mineral soil that is harmless, because the two are genuinely similar. In a peat it is not: the particulate carbon in a Waikato peat is thousands of years old and has already lost everything labile. Giving it the decay constant of fresh residue predicts losses of 40 t C/ha/yr on drainage instead of the 3 to 6 t C/ha/yr that is actually measured. POMo keeps the two apart. For every non-organic soil the two pools behave identically, so nothing else changes.
只设一个颗粒态库,就会迫使本季的根系凋落物与土壤原有的有机质共用一个分解常数。在矿质土壤中这无伤大雅,因为两者确实相近。在泥炭中则不然:Waikato 泥炭中的颗粒态碳已有数千年历史,所有活性组分早已损失殆尽。赋予它新鲜残体的分解常数,预测出的排水后损失将是 40 t C/ha/yr,而不是实测的 3 至 6 t C/ha/yr。POMo 把两者分开。对于所有非有机土壤,这两个库的行为完全相同,因此其他一切都不受影响。
Order of operations within a month一个月内的运算顺序
- Find which phase of the rotation is running, and set the root depth distribution.
- Compute soil temperature at each horizon's midpoint.
- Run the water balance: rain, irrigation, drainage, evapotranspiration, water table.
- Add this month's plant carbon: litter, root litter, exudates; take out what is grazed, cut or burnt, and return dung.
- Add any organic amendment applied this month.
- Cultivate, if a pass falls in this month.
- Decompose the surface layers.
- Decompose each horizon in turn, from the top down, carrying dissolved carbon downward.
- 确定轮作正处于哪个阶段,并设定根系的深度分布。
- 计算每个土层中点处的土壤温度。
- 运行水分平衡:降雨、灌溉、排水、蒸散、地下水位。
- 加入本月的植物碳:凋落物、根系凋落物、分泌物;扣除被采食、刈割或焚烧的部分,并归还粪。
- 加入本月施用的任何有机改良剂。
- 如果本月有一次耕作作业,则进行耕作。
- 分解地表各层。
- 自上而下依次分解每个土层,并把溶解态碳向下传递。
2From concentrations to stocks从含量到储量
A carbon percentage means nothing until it is multiplied by the mass of fine earth actually present, which is why bulk density and coarse fragments are not optional extras. For a horizon of thickness z centimetres:
碳的百分含量只有乘以实际存在的细土质量才有意义,这就是为什么容重和粗碎屑不是可有可无的附加项。对于厚度为 z 厘米的土层:
where ρb is bulk density in g/cm³, fcoarse is the volume fraction of stones over 2 mm, and 100 converts 1 cm of soil at 1 g/cm³ over one hectare into tonnes. Carbon stock is then Mfine × C% / 100.
其中 ρb 是容重,单位 g/cm³;fcoarse 是大于 2 mm 的石砾所占的体积分数;100 用于把一公顷范围内 1 cm 厚、容重 1 g/cm³ 的土壤换算为吨。于是碳储量为 Mfine × C% / 100。
Splitting the starting stock拆分初始储量
The inert fraction at the start of a run follows Falloon et al. (1998):
运行开始时的惰性组分按 Falloon et al. (1998) 计算:
with TOC and IOM both in t C/ha, capped at a quarter of the total. The particulate share comes from the horizon's POM fraction and the microbial share from its microbial fraction; whatever is left is mineral-associated.
TOC 和 IOM 的单位均为 t C/ha,上限为总量的四分之一。颗粒态份额取自该土层的 POM 比例,微生物份额取自其微生物比例;剩余部分均为矿物结合态。
Mineral saturation capacity矿物饱和容量
Mineral surfaces can only hold so much. Hassink (1997) related the maximum carbon in the fine fraction to the mass of that fraction:
矿物表面能容纳的量是有限的。Hassink (1997) 把细颗粒组分中的最大碳量与该组分的质量联系起来:
with a = 4.09 and b = 0.37 by default. F<20µm is the percentage of particles finer than 20 µm, taken from the texture class. A capFactor multiplies the result for mineralogies Hassink's temperate data set does not cover: allophanic soils (×2.6), pumice (×2.4) and oxidic clays (×1.6), where short-range-order minerals and iron oxides hold far more carbon than particle size alone implies.
默认 a = 4.09,b = 0.37。F<20µm 是细于 20 µm 的颗粒所占百分比,取自质地类别。对于 Hassink 的温带数据集未涵盖的矿物类型,结果再乘以 capFactor:水铝英石土壤(×2.6)、浮石土(×2.4)和氧化物黏土(×1.6);在这些土壤中,短程有序矿物和铁氧化物所容纳的碳远多于仅凭粒径所能推断的量。
Saturation is the most useful thing this model tells you, and the most often ignored. A New Zealand pasture topsoil already holding 85% of its capacity cannot be made to store much more stable carbon, no matter how much compost is applied. The compost will build particulate carbon, which is real but reversible.
饱和是这个模型告诉你的最有用的信息,也是最常被忽视的。一块已达到其容量 85% 的新西兰牧场表土,无论施用多少堆肥,都无法再多储存多少稳定碳。堆肥会积累颗粒态碳,这是真实的,但可以逆转。
3Soil temperature and water土壤温度与水分
Soil temperature土壤温度
Decomposition is driven by soil temperature, but climate records give air temperature. The annual air wave is damped and delayed with depth, and damped again by canopy and litter cover:
驱动分解的是土壤温度,而气候记录给出的是气温。气温的年波动随深度衰减并滞后,又因冠层和凋落物覆盖而进一步衰减:
T̄ is the annual mean air temperature, d the thermal damping depth (2 m by default), ccover a cover factor from the plant library (0.65 under closed native forest, 1.05 on bare soil), and the phase lag τ = 1.91 z/d months. ΔToffset is the amount by which mean annual soil temperature exceeds mean annual air temperature, normally 1 to 2 °C.
T̄ 是年平均气温,d 是热衰减深度(默认 2 m),ccover 是取自植物库的覆盖因子(郁闭原生林下为 0.65,裸土为 1.05),相位滞后 τ = 1.91 z/d 个月。ΔToffset 是年平均土壤温度高出年平均气温的幅度,通常为 1 至 2 °C。
Water balance水分平衡
A cascading bucket, one per horizon. Rain plus irrigation enters the top. Water above field capacity moves down, at a rate set by the drainage class — a well drained soil passes all of it, a very poorly drained soil only a tenth — and anything above saturation always leaves. Water is then withdrawn for evapotranspiration:
级联水桶模型,每个土层一个水桶。降雨加灌溉从顶部进入。超过田间持水量的水向下移动,速率由排水性等级决定 — 排水良好的土壤让其全部通过,排水极差的土壤只让十分之一通过 — 而超过饱和的部分总会流出。随后为蒸散抽取水分:
The first term is transpiration: the crop coefficient times reference evapotranspiration, reduced by a stress factor s = min(1, W̄/0.5), where W̄ is the root-weighted fraction of plant-available water remaining. Plants take water freely until half of it is gone, then increasingly struggle. The second term is evaporation from bare soil, which only matters when the canopy is open. Withdrawal from each horizon is proportional to root density × wetness and never goes below the wilting point, except in the top horizon where direct evaporation can dry the soil further.
第一项是蒸腾:作物系数乘以参考蒸散,再乘以胁迫因子 s = min(1, W̄/0.5) 加以削减,其中 W̄ 是按根系加权的剩余植物有效水比例。植物可以自由取水,直到有效水用去一半,此后取水越来越困难。第二项是裸土蒸发,只有在冠层敞开时才有意义。每个土层的取水量与根系密度 × 湿度成正比,且绝不会低于凋萎点,唯有顶部土层例外,那里的直接蒸发可以使土壤更干。
Water table and water-filled pore space地下水位与充水孔隙度
Porosity is φ = 1 − ρb/2.65. The water table rises and falls with the profile-wide soil moisture deficit:
孔隙度为 φ = 1 − ρb/2.65。地下水位随整个剖面的土壤水分亏缺而升降:
D is the deficit in millimetres and 1.4 cm/mm follows from a specific yield near 0.07. zwt,base comes from the drainage class. fsat is the fraction of the horizon lying below the water table, which is saturated by definition. This is what switches on methanogenesis, so the drainage class is the single most consequential choice on the Soil tab for a wet site.
D 是以毫米计的亏缺量,1.4 cm/mm 由约 0.07 的给水度推得。zwt,base 取自排水性等级。fsat 是土层位于地下水位以下的比例,按定义处于饱和状态。正是它开启了产甲烷作用,因此对于潮湿地点,排水性等级是“土壤”选项卡上后果最重大的单项选择。
4Rate modifiers速率修正因子
Every decay constant in the model is a potential rate: what the pool would do at 10 °C, optimal moisture and pH 6.5. Six dimensionless modifiers scale it down. They are always multiplicative, so realised turnover in the field is always slower than k. A fertiliser and liming regime adds two more — one that speeds the labile pools up and one that slows the humified pool down — and moves the pH that Eq. 3 reads; both are set out in section 10.
模型中的每个分解常数都是潜在速率:即该库在 10 °C、最适湿度和 pH 6.5 条件下的表现。六个无量纲修正因子将其按比例下调。它们总是以相乘方式作用,因此田间实际的周转总是慢于 k。施肥和施石灰制度再增加两个修正因子 — 一个加快活性库,一个减慢腐殖化库 — 并改变方程 3 读取的 pH;两者都在第 10 节中说明。
Temperature温度
Q10 is 2.0 by default. Mineral-associated carbon has a higher activation energy, so it uses Q10 + 0.3.
Q10 默认为 2.0。矿物结合碳的活化能更高,因此它使用 Q10 + 0.3。
Moisture湿度
W is water-filled pore space, Wopt = 0.60. Below the optimum, substrate diffusion limits the microbes; above it, oxygen diffusion does. With the default exponents the function gives 0.28 at WFPS 0.10, 1.00 at 0.60, 0.59 at 0.80 and 0.07 at saturation.
W 是充水孔隙度,Wopt = 0.60。低于最适值时,底物扩散限制微生物;高于最适值时,氧气扩散成为限制。采用默认指数时,该函数在 WFPS 0.10 时为 0.28,0.60 时为 1.00,0.80 时为 0.59,饱和时为 0.07。
pH
An asymmetric Gaussian with pHopt = 6.5, a narrower width on the acid side (1.8) than the alkaline side (2.4). A soil at pH 5.0 decomposes at half the rate of the same soil at pH 6.5.
一个非对称高斯函数,pHopt = 6.5,酸性一侧的宽度(1.8)比碱性一侧(2.4)窄。同一种土壤在 pH 5.0 时的分解速率是 pH 6.5 时的一半。
Nitrogen availability氮有效性
Applied to the soil's own C:N ratio, acting on the mineral-associated pool. Above the critical ratio of about 25, microbes must immobilise mineral nitrogen to build cells, and mineralisation slows.
作用于土壤自身的 C:N 比,影响矿物结合库。当 C:N 比高于约 25 的临界值时,微生物必须固持矿质氮来构建细胞,矿化随之减慢。
Litter quality凋落物质量
The lignin-to-nitrogen ratio is the classic single predictor of litter decomposition rate (Melillo et al. 1982). Using the ratio rather than separate lignin and nitrogen multipliers avoids penalising woody litter twice for the same property, which would otherwise make forest litter decompose implausibly slowly. Pasture litter (LN ≈ 1.9) decomposes at 86% of its potential rate, wheat straw (LN ≈ 24) at 33%, pine litter (LN ≈ 40) at 23%. Above-ground values apply in the top horizon and root values below.
木质素与氮之比是预测凋落物分解速率的经典单一指标(Melillo et al. 1982)。使用这一比值,而不是分别设置木质素和氮的乘数,可以避免因同一性质对木质凋落物惩罚两次,否则森林凋落物的分解会慢得不合情理。牧草凋落物(LN ≈ 1.9)以其潜在速率的 86% 分解,小麦秸秆(LN ≈ 24)为 33%,松树凋落物(LN ≈ 40)为 23%。顶部土层采用地上部分的数值,其下土层采用根系的数值。
Mineral protection矿物保护
Applied only to the mineral-associated pool. Specific surface area is estimated from texture class where it has not been measured: under 2 m²/g for a quartz sand, 20 to 60 for a loam, over 100 for a smectitic clay, and 100 to 600 for an allophanic soil. Note the division of labour: surface area sets how strongly carbon is held and how much dissolved carbon sorbs; the fine fraction sets how much can be held at all. Using one property for both would double-count it.
只作用于矿物结合库。未经测定时,比表面积根据质地类别估算:石英砂低于 2 m²/g,壤土为 20 至 60,蒙皂石类黏土超过 100,水铝英石土壤为 100 至 600。注意两者的分工:表面积决定碳被结合得多牢固以及有多少溶解态碳被吸附;细颗粒组分决定总共能容纳多少碳。用同一个性质同时承担两者,就会重复计算。
5Carbon inputs碳输入
Above-ground net primary production for the month is the annual figure times that month's share of the growth curve. Below-ground production follows from the root:shoot ratio, and both are converted to carbon with the plant's carbon fraction.
当月的地上净初级生产量等于全年数值乘以该月在生长曲线中所占的份额。地下生产量由根冠比推得,两者都用该植物的碳含量比例换算为碳。
ra is autotrophic respiration as a fraction of gross primary production, about 0.5 for herbaceous plants and 0.55 for forest. GPP is reported in the mass balance but does not otherwise enter the model.
ra 是自养呼吸占总初级生产量的比例,草本植物约为 0.5,森林约为 0.55。GPP 在质量平衡中报告,但不以其他方式进入模型。
Where above-ground carbon goes地上部分的碳去向何处
A fraction is laid down as long-lived wood and does not reach the soil this year; it is reported separately so the account still balances. Of what remains, a fraction is grazed in place, a fraction is cut and carted off, and the rest falls as litter. A burnt fraction is emitted immediately as CO2, apart from a small pyrogenic residue that joins the inert pool.
一部分沉积为长寿命的木材,当年不会进入土壤;这部分单独报告,以使账目仍然平衡。其余部分中,一部分在原地被采食,一部分被刈割运走,剩下的作为凋落物落下。被焚烧的部分立即以 CO2 形式排放,只有一小部分热解残余物进入惰性库。
Grazing放牧
Intake carbon is partitioned by the livestock library:
采食摄入的碳按牲畜库进行分配:
| Fate of intake carbon摄入碳的去向 | Dairy奶牛 | Beef肉牛 | Sheep绵羊 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Returned as dung以粪的形式归还 | 0.30 | 0.34 | 0.32 |
| Returned as urine以尿的形式归还 | 0.03 | 0.02 | 0.02 |
| Leaves in animal product随畜产品离开 | 0.10 | 0.05 | 0.05 |
| Enteric methane肠道甲烷 | 0.060 | 0.065 | 0.060 |
| Animal respiration动物呼吸 | the balance其余部分 | the balance其余部分 | the balance其余部分 |
Dung is partly humified already, so a share of its carbon goes straight to the mineral-associated pool and the rest joins the surface litter.
粪已部分腐殖化,因此其碳的一部分直接进入矿物结合库,其余部分加入地表凋落物。
Below-ground carbon地下部分的碳
Roots are distributed with depth by Gale & Grigal (1987): the cumulative fraction above depth d centimetres is 1 − βd. A fraction of below-ground production is released as exudates and rhizodeposits, which are taken up by microbes almost immediately; the rest becomes root litter and joins the particulate pool of each horizon in proportion to root density. Roots below the modelled profile are folded into the deepest horizon so nothing is lost from the account.
根系随深度的分布采用 Gale & Grigal (1987):深度 d 厘米以上的累积比例为 1 − βd。地下生产量的一部分以分泌物和根际沉积物的形式释放,几乎立即被微生物吸收;其余部分成为根系凋落物,按根系密度比例进入各土层的颗粒态库。模拟剖面以下的根系并入最深的土层,因此账目中不会遗漏任何部分。
Below-ground inputs build soil carbon far more effectively than surface inputs. Two mechanisms in the model produce this: exudates are taken up by rhizosphere microbes already attached to mineral surfaces, so their necromass stabilises more efficiently (the exudate stabilisation bonus); and root carbon is delivered directly to depth, where it meets unsaturated mineral surfaces instead of the near-saturated topsoil.
地下输入积累土壤碳的效果远好于地表输入。模型中有两个机制造成这一点:分泌物被已附着在矿物表面的根际微生物吸收,因此其残体的稳定化效率更高(分泌物稳定化加成);根系碳被直接输送到深处,在那里遇到的是未饱和的矿物表面,而不是接近饱和的表土。
Amendments改良剂
Each material is split three ways: an inert pyrogenic part straight to IOM, an already-humified part that sorbs to mineral surfaces, and a labile remainder that joins the surface mulch or, if incorporated, the particulate pool of the cultivated layer. Imported feed is routed through the livestock partition instead, since it only reaches the soil as dung.
每种材料被分为三部分:惰性热解部分直接进入 IOM,已腐殖化的部分吸附到矿物表面,活性的剩余部分加入地表覆盖物,若混入土壤则进入耕作层的颗粒态库。外购饲料则改经牲畜分配处理,因为它只以粪的形式到达土壤。
6Decomposition and stabilisation分解与稳定化
Each pool loses carbon by first-order decay. The exponential form is used rather than a simple product so the result is stable even when the monthly loss is large:
每个库都按一级动力学分解损失碳。这里使用指数形式而不是简单乘积,使得即便当月损失很大,结果也保持稳定:
E is the product of the relevant modifiers from section 4 and Δt = 1/12 year. For the particulate pool E = fT A fpH fQ ftill; for the mineral-associated pool E = fT,MAOM A fpH fN fprot ftill,MAOM, where A is the oxygen-corrected activity from section 7.
E 是第 4 节中相关修正因子的乘积,Δt = 1/12 年。对颗粒态库,E = fT A fpH fQ ftill;对矿物结合库,E = fT,MAOM A fpH fN fprot ftill,MAOM,其中 A 是第 7 节中经氧气校正的活性。
Microbial uptake微生物吸收
Everything released by decomposition, plus exudates and the products of surface-layer breakdown, forms a pool of free carbon. Part dissolves; the rest is taken up by microbes and split between biomass and respiration by the carbon use efficiency:
分解释放的全部碳,加上分泌物和地表层分解的产物,构成一个游离碳库。其中一部分溶解;其余被微生物吸收,并按碳利用效率在生物量和呼吸之间分配:
Efficiency falls as the soil warms, because maintenance respiration rises faster than growth, and falls again under anoxia where metabolism yields far less energy per unit of carbon.
效率随土壤升温而下降,因为维持呼吸比生长增加得更快;在缺氧条件下效率再次下降,因为此时代谢从单位碳中获得的能量要少得多。
Necromass and stabilisation微生物残体与稳定化
Microbes die at a first-order rate. What happens to the necromass is the heart of the model, because it is the only route from plant carbon to stable soil carbon:
微生物按一级速率死亡。微生物残体的去向是模型的核心,因为这是植物碳变为稳定土壤碳的唯一途径:
ε is the fraction of necromass that sorbs to mineral surfaces and becomes MAOM; the remainder becomes particulate. It falls to zero as the mineral surfaces fill. βex is the exudate stabilisation bonus and φex the share of this month's substrate that arrived as exudate. The same saturation limit is applied to every route into MAOM — amendments, dung and sorbed dissolved carbon included — so the capacity cannot be bypassed.
ε 是吸附到矿物表面并成为 MAOM 的微生物残体比例;其余成为颗粒态。随着矿物表面被填满,它降至零。βex 是分泌物稳定化加成,φex 是本月底物中以分泌物形式到达的份额。同一饱和限制适用于进入 MAOM 的每一条途径 — 包括改良剂、粪和被吸附的溶解态碳 — 因此容量无法被绕过。
7Carbon dioxide and methane二氧化碳与甲烷
Above a threshold water-filled pore space, oxygen diffusion cannot keep up with demand and part of the horizon respires anaerobically. Anaerobic metabolism is slow but does not stop, so the combined activity is a weighted mixture rather than simply the moisture response:
当充水孔隙度超过某个阈值时,氧气扩散跟不上需求,土层的一部分转为厌氧呼吸。厌氧代谢缓慢,但不会停止,因此综合活性是一个加权混合,而不只是湿度响应:
Wanox is about 0.68 and ranaer, the anaerobic rate as a fraction of the aerobic optimum, about 0.15. That ratio is the reason peat accumulates under water and disappears once it is drained.
Wanox 约为 0.68,ranaer(厌氧速率占好氧最适速率的比例)约为 0.15。正是这个比值,使泥炭在水下积累,而一经排水便消失。
The anaerobic share of respiration is split between carbon dioxide and methane by the methanogenic fraction, about 0.5, which is what acetoclastic methanogenesis gives. Methane then has to escape through whatever aerobic soil lies above it, where methanotrophs consume it. That oxidation is first order along the path out:
呼吸中的厌氧部分按产甲烷比例(约 0.5,即乙酸裂解型产甲烷作用给出的值)在二氧化碳和甲烷之间分配。甲烷随后必须穿过其上方的好氧土壤才能逸出,在那里被甲烷氧化菌消耗。这一氧化沿逸出路径呈一级动力学:
zaer is the thickness of aerobic soil above the horizon in centimetres and fox the fraction oxidised in the first 20 cm. A wetland with the water table at the surface loses almost all of its methane to the atmosphere; the same soil with the water table at 60 cm loses almost none. Well drained soils are treated as a small net methane sink.
zaer 是该土层上方好氧土壤的厚度(厘米),fox 是最上面 20 cm 内被氧化的比例。地下水位位于地表的湿地,几乎所有甲烷都散失到大气中;同一土壤若地下水位在 60 cm,则几乎没有散失。排水良好的土壤被视为一个小的甲烷净汇。
8Dissolved organic carbon溶解性有机碳
A fraction of everything released by decomposition enters solution rather than being respired or assimilated. Dissolved carbon produced in a horizon joins whatever percolated in from above. How much leaves depends on how much water drained relative to how much is held:
分解释放的全部碳中,有一部分进入溶液,而不是被呼吸或同化。某土层中产生的溶解态碳与从上方渗入的部分汇合。离开多少取决于排出的水量与持有的水量之比:
Q is the month's drainage through the horizon in millimetres and θ its water content. Sorbed carbon joins the mineral-associated pool of that horizon, subject to its saturation limit; carbon that neither leaves nor sorbs is consumed in place. Whatever is still in solution at the base of the profile has left the system, and is reported as leached dissolved organic carbon.
Q 是当月通过该土层的排水量(毫米),θ 是其含水量。被吸附的碳进入该土层的矿物结合库,受其饱和限制约束;既未离开也未被吸附的碳在原地被消耗。到剖面底部仍处于溶液中的碳即已离开系统,报告为淋失的溶解性有机碳。
This is the mechanism that builds subsoil carbon in a podzol, and the reason a high specific surface area matters at depth as well as in the topsoil.
这正是灰化土中底土碳得以积累的机制,也是高比表面积不仅在表土、而且在深层同样重要的原因。
9Cultivation and mixing耕作与混合
A cultivation pass does three things. It homogenises every pool through the working depth, weighted by each horizon's fine-earth mass. It buries the surface litter and mulch as particulate carbon. And it starts a decomposition pulse as aggregates break and occluded particulate carbon is exposed to microbes:
一次耕作作业做三件事。它在整个耕作深度内按各土层的细土质量加权,把每个库混合均匀。它把地表凋落物和覆盖物作为颗粒态碳埋入土中。它还会引发一次分解脉冲,因为团聚体破碎,被包裹的颗粒态碳暴露给微生物:
P is the pulse multiplier (about 1.9), t the months since the pass, and h the half-life (about 4 months) over which aggregates re-form. Only a fraction of the pulse is applied to the mineral-associated pool, because cultivation exposes mainly particulate carbon.
P 是脉冲乘数(约 1.9),t 是距该次作业的月数,h 是团聚体重新形成的半衰期(约 4 个月)。只有一部分脉冲作用于矿物结合库,因为耕作暴露的主要是颗粒态碳。
Between cultivations, soil fauna carry particulate carbon downward from each horizon to the one below at a first-order bioturbation rate, and drag surface litter into the A horizon at the litter incorporation rate. In an earthworm-rich pasture soil that second flux is large.
在两次耕作之间,土壤动物以一级生物扰动速率把颗粒态碳从每个土层向下带到下一层,并以凋落物混入速率把地表凋落物拖入 A 层。在蚯蚓丰富的牧场土壤中,后一种通量很大。
Why cultivation is snapped to whole horizons为什么耕作要对齐到整个土层
Each horizon is represented by a single value for each pool. If a plough pass were allowed to mix only the top few centimetres of the horizon below, that carbon would immediately be treated as though it were spread through the whole of that horizon — where the subsoil's large unused mineral capacity would stabilise it. Repeated every year, the model would turn ploughing into a carbon pump and report cultivation as beneficial, which is the opposite of what is observed.
每个土层的每个库只用一个数值表示。如果允许一次犁耕只混合下方土层最上面的几厘米,这些碳会立即被当作分布于整个下方土层 — 在那里,底土大量未被利用的矿物容量会将其稳定下来。年复一年重复,模型就会把犁耕变成一台碳泵,报告耕作有益,而这与观测结果恰恰相反。
Cultivation is therefore snapped to the nearest horizon boundary at or above the depth entered. To model deep ploughing, set the A horizon's base to the plough depth: a deep plough layer is a deep A horizon, and representing it that way keeps the physics honest. With the artefact removed, turning cultivation off in the Canterbury arable rotation adds about 5 t C/ha at equilibrium, in continuous maize about 12 t C/ha, and in an intensive vegetable rotation with three passes a year about 21 t C/ha.
因此,耕作深度会对齐到输入深度处或其上方最近的土层边界。要模拟深耕,请把 A 层的底界设为犁耕深度:深厚的犁耕层就是深厚的 A 层,这样表示能让物理过程保持真实。去除这一假象后,在 Canterbury 大田作物轮作中关闭耕作,平衡时约增加 5 t C/ha;连作玉米约增加 12 t C/ha;每年耕作三次的集约蔬菜轮作约增加 21 t C/ha。
10Fertiliser, lime and nitrogen肥料、石灰与氮
Soil organic carbon is oxidised by microorganisms, so a model of it is a model of what those organisms are able to do. Two of the strongest controls on that are the nitrogen supply and the pH, and both are set by what is spread on the block. A fertiliser and liming regime is therefore an input to this model, not a commentary on its output.
土壤有机碳由微生物氧化,因此土壤有机碳模型就是关于这些微生物能做什么的模型。对此最强的两个控制因素是氮供应和 pH,而两者都由施到地块上的东西决定。因此,施肥和施石灰制度是这个模型的一项输入,而不是对其输出的评注。
The whole of this section is inert while the Fertiliser tab is switched off: the nitrogen availability index is then zero, no lime or acid is applied, and every expression below reduces to one. A run without a regime gives exactly the numbers the model gave before the regime existed, which is what makes the comparison between the two meaningful.
当“肥料与石灰”选项卡关闭时,本节全部内容都不起作用:此时氮有效性指数为零,不施加任何石灰或酸,下面每个表达式都化为 1。不带施肥制度的运行给出的数字,与引入施肥制度之前模型给出的数字完全相同,这正是两者之间的比较有意义的原因。
Nitrogen supply氮供应
Three sources are added, in kilograms of nitrogen per hectare per year: fertiliser nitrogen as entered; nitrogen mineralised within the year from the organic materials in the imports panel, taken as each material's carbon input divided by its C:N ratio and multiplied by an available fraction of about 0.3; and, only if asked for, the nitrogen stock return in dung and urine. The last is off by default because it is internal recycling: the production figures in the plant library were measured on grazed swards and already contain it, so counting it again would double it.
三个来源相加,单位为每公顷每年千克氮:按输入值计的肥料氮;“有机物输入”面板中各有机材料在当年内矿化的氮,取每种材料的碳输入除以其 C:N 比,再乘以约 0.3 的有效比例;以及仅在选择时才计入的、牲畜通过粪和尿归还的氮。最后一项默认关闭,因为它属于内部再循环:植物库中的产量数据是在放牧草地上测得的,已经包含了它,再计一次就会重复计算。
The total is turned into a dimensionless index that saturates:
总量被转换为一个会饱和的无量纲指数:
Nhalf is 90 kg N/ha/yr, so a New Zealand dairy platform at 150 kg N/ha/yr sits at about 0.63 and a cut-and-carry block with no nitrogen sits at zero.
Nhalf 为 90 kg N/ha/yr,因此施氮 150 kg N/ha/yr 的新西兰奶牛场挤奶平台约为 0.63,而不施氮的刈割运出地块为零。
What nitrogen does to decomposition氮对分解的作用
It does two opposite things, and the model has to carry both or it will get the sign wrong. Nitrogen-poor plant residue decomposes slowly because the microbes attacking it must immobilise mineral nitrogen to build cells; supply that nitrogen and the constraint is relieved. But the same mineral nitrogen represses the oxidative, ligninolytic enzyme systems that break down condensed, humified material, so the older and more processed the carbon, the more nitrogen slows it down. This is the pattern Fog (1988) set out, Berg and Matzner (1997) confirmed in litter, and the meta-analysis of Janssens et al. (2010) measured across temperate systems as a net reduction of roughly 15% in heterotrophic soil respiration.
它做两件相反的事,模型必须同时体现两者,否则就会把符号弄错。贫氮植物残体分解缓慢,因为分解它的微生物必须固持矿质氮来构建细胞;供应了氮,这一约束就得以解除。但同样的矿质氮会抑制分解缩合态、腐殖化物质的氧化性木质素降解酶系统,因此碳越老、被加工得越彻底,氮对其分解的减缓作用就越大。这是 Fog (1988) 提出的规律,Berg and Matzner (1997) 在凋落物中加以证实,Janssens et al. (2010) 的荟萃分析则在温带各系统中测得其为异养土壤呼吸净减少约 15%。
Applied to surface litter, to surface mulch and to the particulate pool. fQ is that material's own quality modifier from Eq. 5 (or Eq. 4 for mulch), so the acceleration is proportional to how nitrogen-limited the substrate already is: straw and wood chip speed up, a fertilised clover sward does not speed up twice. alab is 0.20.
作用于地表凋落物、地表覆盖物和颗粒态库。fQ 是该材料自身由方程 5(覆盖物则为方程 4)得出的质量修正因子,因此加速程度与底物原本受氮限制的程度成正比:秸秆和木屑分解加快,而施过肥的三叶草草地不会被加速两次。alab 为 0.20。
Applied to the mineral-associated pool, with ahum = 0.15 and a floor of 0.3 so the pool can never be switched off entirely.
作用于矿物结合库,ahum = 0.15,下限为 0.3,因此该库永远不会被完全关闭。
Microbes that are not short of nitrogen respire less of the carbon they take up and build more of it into biomass, and biomass becomes necromass, which is the raw material of mineral-associated carbon. aCUE = 0.10. This adjusts the base efficiency CUE0 that section 6 then reduces for temperature and for anoxia; it does not replace either of those.
不缺氮的微生物会把吸收的碳更少地用于呼吸、更多地构建为生物量,而生物量会变为微生物残体,后者正是矿物结合碳的原料。aCUE = 0.10。它调整的是基础效率 CUE0,第 6 节随后再针对温度和缺氧对其进行下调;它不取代这两者中的任何一个。
Acidity, lime and pH酸度、石灰与 pH
Nitrification of fertiliser ammonium generates acid; lime consumes it. Both are expressed in the form a lime recommendation already uses — tonnes of calcium carbonate equivalent per hectare per year — so the two can simply be subtracted. The acidity per kilogram of nitrogen depends on the source and on how much of the resulting nitrate the plant takes up rather than losing to drainage: the conventional field figures are 1.8 kg CaCO3 per kg N for urea, 5.4 for ammonium sulphate and 3.6 for DAP, against theoretical limits of nothing and about 7.1. All of them are editable.
肥料中铵的硝化产生酸;石灰消耗酸。两者都以石灰推荐方案本来使用的形式表示 — 每公顷每年碳酸钙当量吨数 — 因此可以直接相减。每千克氮产生的酸度取决于氮源,也取决于所生成的硝酸盐有多少被植物吸收、而不是随排水损失:常规田间数值为尿素每 kg N 1.8 kg CaCO3,硫酸铵 5.4,DAP 3.6,理论极限则为零和约 7.1。所有这些数值都可编辑。
Applied once a year. L is the lime applied as CaCO3 equivalent, A the acid load, B0 the tonnes of carbonate needed to move the limed layer by one pH unit near pH 6 (9 t/ha by default, which is the New Zealand rule of thumb that four to five tonnes of lime lifts pH by about half a unit), and sh the share of horizon h that lies inside the limed layer. The buffer is not constant: below pH 6 the hydrolysis of exchangeable aluminium takes up acid in place of the soil solution, and above it base saturation approaches its ceiling and further carbonate simply accumulates, so r = 1.0 makes each successive pH unit cost more than the last and the trajectory approaches an asymptote instead of running away. pH is clamped to 3.5 to 8.4.
每年应用一次。L 是以 CaCO3 当量计的石灰施用量,A 是酸负荷,B0 是在 pH 6 附近使施石灰层的 pH 改变一个单位所需的碳酸盐吨数(默认 9 t/ha,对应新西兰的经验法则:四到五吨石灰使 pH 提高约半个单位),sh 是土层 h 位于施石灰层内的份额。缓冲能力并非常数:pH 6 以下,可交换铝的水解代替土壤溶液吸收了酸;pH 6 以上,盐基饱和度接近其上限,多施的碳酸盐只是累积下来,因此 r = 1.0 使每提高一个 pH 单位的代价都比上一个更高,轨迹趋近一条渐近线,而不是失控上升。pH 被限定在 3.5 至 8.4 之间。
Two rules keep this honest. Maintenance lime stops once the limed layer reaches its target pH, because that is what a maintenance lime recommendation is for; without that test a standing order for lime would carry a soil to pH 8 over a long run, which no farm has ever managed. And the pH does not move during equilibration: the pH entered in the Soil tab is a measurement of the soil as it is now, and the trajectory describes the change from there under the regime entered, not three hundred years of invented history.
有两条规则保证这一过程真实可信。一旦施石灰层达到目标 pH,维持性石灰就停止施用,因为维持性石灰推荐方案本来就是为此而设;没有这一检验,长期运行中的常设石灰施用会把土壤推到 pH 8,而这是任何农场都从未做到过的。其次,pH 在预热运行期间不发生变化:在“土壤”选项卡中输入的 pH 是对土壤当前状态的测量,轨迹描述的是在所输入的制度下从这一状态出发的变化,而不是三百年虚构的历史。
The pH so obtained feeds straight into Eq. 3, which multiplies every decay constant in the model. That is the mechanism behind the oldest observation in the subject — lime an acid soil and its organic matter starts to go — and it is usually the largest single effect a fertiliser regime has on the carbon line.
这样得到的 pH 直接输入方程 3,而方程 3 乘到模型中的每个分解常数上。这就是该领域最古老的观察背后的机制 — 给酸性土壤施石灰,其有机质就开始流失 — 而这通常也是施肥制度对碳曲线影响最大的单一效应。
Production产量
Diminishing returns with an initial slope c of 10 kg DM per kg N and Nsat = 250 kg N/ha/yr, so 150 kg N/ha/yr on fully responsive pasture adds about 1.1 t DM/ha/yr. kplant scales it per plant (data/fertiliser.js): 1.0 for ryegrass and the cereals, 0.1 for lucerne, which fixes its own, 0.05 for mature native forest and 0 for a bare fallow. Grazing returns are excluded from Nfert+org here for the same reason as above, and a production figure pinned in the Production overrides table is left alone entirely: a typed figure is a measurement of the block as it is farmed now and already contains its own response. Without this equation nitrogen would appear in the model as nothing but a cost, which is wrong.
报酬递减,初始斜率 c 为每 kg N 10 kg DM,Nsat = 250 kg N/ha/yr,因此在完全有响应的牧场上施 150 kg N/ha/yr 约增加 1.1 t DM/ha/yr。kplant 按植物对其进行缩放(data/fertiliser.js):黑麦草和谷物为 1.0,自身固氮的紫花苜蓿为 0.1,成熟原生林为 0.05,裸地休耕为 0。出于与上文相同的理由,这里的 Nfert+org 不包括放牧归还;而在“覆盖生产力”表中固定的产量数据则完全不作调整:手动输入的数字是对地块当前经营状态的测量,已经包含了其自身的响应。没有这个方程,氮在模型中就只会表现为一项代价,而这是错误的。
The carbon in the lime石灰中的碳
Agricultural limestone is about 12% carbon by mass, and that carbon leaves as carbon dioxide as the carbonate dissolves — roughly 108 kg C per tonne of product spread. It is not soil organic carbon and it never was, so it is kept out of the pools and out of the Net Ecosystem Carbon Balance, and reported on its own line beneath the mass balance. Burnt and hydrated lime carry no carbonate carbon at all; their carbon dioxide was released in the kiln, which is upstream of this model.
农用石灰石按质量计约含 12% 的碳,这些碳随碳酸盐溶解以二氧化碳形式离开 — 每施用一吨产品约 108 kg C。它不是土壤有机碳,也从来不是,因此它被排除在各个库和净生态系统碳平衡之外,在质量平衡下方单列一行报告。生石灰和熟石灰完全不含碳酸盐碳;它们的二氧化碳在石灰窑中就已释放,那发生在本模型的上游。
11Mass balance and NECB质量平衡与 NECB
Every flux is tallied over the run. The Net Ecosystem Carbon Balance is the net flux across the boundary of the block:
每一项通量都在整个运行期间累计。净生态系统碳平衡是穿过地块边界的净通量:
I is imported organic matter, H harvest, Panimal animal product, Ranimal animal respiration, B burning, Rh heterotrophic soil respiration and W carbon accumulating in woody biomass. A positive NECB means the block gained carbon.
I 是输入的有机物,H 是收获,Panimal 是畜产品,Ranimal 是动物呼吸,B 是焚烧,Rh 是异养土壤呼吸,W 是在木质生物量中累积的碳。NECB 为正值表示地块获得了碳。
NECB is computed from the fluxes, and the change in soil plus litter carbon is computed from the pools. They should be equal. The model reports the difference as a closure error, and the interface raises a warning if it exceeds 1% of the inputs. In normal use it is under a tenth of a tonne over fifty years.
NECB 由通量计算,土壤加凋落物碳的变化由各库计算。两者应当相等。模型把差值报告为闭合误差,若超过输入量的 1%,界面会发出警告。在正常使用中,五十年间它不到十分之一吨。
12Uncertainty不确定性
Every uncertain quantity carries a minimum, a nominative value and a maximum. The central run uses the nominative values throughout. The uncertainty run repeats the whole simulation, drawing each quantity from a triangular distribution on its three values:
每个不确定的量都带有一个最小值、一个名义值和一个最大值。中心运行全部采用名义值。不确定性运行则重复整个模拟,每个量都从由其三个数值构成的三角分布中抽样:
with a the minimum, c the nominative value and b the maximum. Triangular is used because those three numbers are exactly what the parameter library provides, and it uses them without inventing anything further.
其中 a 为最小值,c 为名义值,b 为最大值。之所以采用三角分布,是因为这三个数字正是参数库所提供的,而三角分布使用它们时不再额外虚构任何东西。
All uncertain quantities are resampled together within a run, so the band shows the combined effect rather than one parameter at a time. The shaded band is the 5th to 95th percentile across runs. The generator is seeded, so a quoted result can be reproduced exactly.
在一次运行中,所有不确定的量一起重新抽样,因此区间显示的是综合效应,而不是一次一个参数的效应。阴影区间是各次运行的第 5 至第 95 百分位数。随机数生成器设有种子,因此引用的结果可以精确重现。
The band is usually wide, and that is the honest answer. The decay constant for mineral-associated carbon is uncertain by a factor of about five, and it dominates any prediction beyond a decade. If your band spans zero, the model is telling you that the direction of change cannot be resolved from published parameters alone, and that you need site data — a repeat measurement, a radiocarbon age, or a long-term incubation.
区间通常很宽,而这就是诚实的答案。矿物结合碳的分解常数的不确定性约为五倍,它主导着十年以上的任何预测。如果你的区间跨越零,模型是在告诉你:仅凭已发表的参数无法判定变化的方向,你需要地点数据 — 一次重复测量、一个放射性碳年龄,或一次长期培养试验。
13Assumptions and limits假设与局限
What is assumed做了哪些假设
- Plant biomass is at steady state apart from the woody increment, which is tracked separately. Establishment years and the removal of standing biomass at harvest are not represented.
- Root litter enters within the year it is produced. Fine root turnover is fast enough for this to hold in pasture and crops; in forest it slightly advances the timing of carbon inputs.
- Horizons are internally uniform. Real profiles have gradients within a horizon, particularly the topsoil under no-till.
- Nitrogen is an input, not a state variable. The nitrogen supply set in the Fertiliser tab acts on decomposition, on carbon use efficiency and on production (section 10), and the acid it generates moves the pH through the run. But there is no nitrogen pool: the model does not track mineralisation, immobilisation, leaching or denitrification, C:N ratios are entered rather than computed, and nitrogen limitation therefore cannot develop by itself over the course of a run. Nitrous oxide is not modelled at all, which matters to the greenhouse balance of a grazed system.
- The rotation repeats unchanged for the whole run, and climate is the same every year apart from any warming trend.
- 植物生物量处于稳态,木质增量除外,后者单独追踪。建植年份以及收获时地上现存生物量的移除均未体现。
- 根系凋落物在其产生的当年进入土壤。细根周转足够快,这一点在牧场和作物中成立;在森林中,它会使碳输入的时间略微提前。
- 土层内部是均一的。真实剖面在土层内部存在梯度,免耕下的表土尤其如此。
- 氮是一项输入,而不是状态变量。在“肥料与石灰”选项卡中设定的氮供应作用于分解、碳利用效率和产量(第 10 节),其产生的酸会在运行过程中改变 pH。但模型没有氮库:它不追踪矿化、固持、淋失或反硝化,C:N 比是输入值而不是计算值,因此氮限制无法在运行过程中自行形成。氧化亚氮完全没有模拟,而这对放牧系统的温室气体平衡有影响。
- 轮作在整个运行期间原样重复,除任何增温趋势外,每年的气候都相同。
What is not modelled哪些没有模拟
- Erosion and deposition. On steep hill country this can dominate the carbon balance of a given point, and the model will not show it.
- Nitrous oxide. It matters greatly to the greenhouse balance of a grazed system, but it is a nitrogen flux, not a carbon one.
- Priming: the acceleration of old carbon decomposition by fresh input. There is good evidence it exists; there is no agreed way to parameterise it.
- Soil fauna other than as a bulk bioturbation rate.
- Preferential flow. Dissolved carbon is assumed to move with the bulk water flux, which understates leaching in a structured clay soil.
- Lateral flow, run-off and irrigation-return flows.
- 侵蚀与沉积。在陡峭的丘陵地区,它们可能主导某一点的碳平衡,而模型不会显示这一点。
- 氧化亚氮。它对放牧系统的温室气体平衡影响很大,但它是氮通量,不是碳通量。
- 激发效应:新鲜输入加速老碳的分解。有充分证据表明它存在;但没有公认的参数化方法。
- 土壤动物,除了作为一个总体生物扰动速率之外。
- 优先流。假定溶解态碳随整体水流运动,这会低估结构性黏土中的淋失。
- 侧向流、径流和灌溉回流。
A known disagreement worth stating一个值得说明的已知分歧
Repeated sampling of New Zealand dairy pasture on Allophanic soils has found carbon losses of roughly 1 t C/ha/yr. Run with library values, this model usually shows those soils as approximately stable or slowly gaining. The mechanism behind the measured loss is still contested — proposals include the effects of nitrogen fertiliser on decomposition, drainage changes, and sampling and bulk-density artefacts — and none of them is settled enough to encode. The model has not been tuned to reproduce the observation, because doing so would hide a genuine open question behind a fitted constant. If you are modelling that system, treat the result as a hypothesis and say so.
对 Allophanic Soils 上新西兰奶牛场牧场的重复采样发现,碳损失约为 1 t C/ha/yr。使用库中数值运行时,本模型通常显示这些土壤大致稳定或缓慢增加。实测损失背后的机制仍有争议 — 提出的解释包括氮肥对分解的影响、排水条件的改变,以及采样和容重造成的假象 — 而其中没有一个已确定到可以写入模型的程度。模型没有为重现这一观测而调参,因为那样做会把一个真正悬而未决的问题藏在一个拟合常数后面。如果你在模拟这一系统,请把结果当作一个假说,并明确这样说明。
References the parameter values draw on参数值所依据的参考文献
- Berg, B. & Matzner, E. (1997) Effect of nitrogen deposition on decomposition of plant litter and soil organic matter in forest systems. Environmental Reviews 5, 1–25.
- Fog, K. (1988) The effect of added nitrogen on the rate of decomposition of organic matter. Biological Reviews 63, 433–462.
- Janssens, I.A. et al. (2010) Reduction of forest soil respiration in response to nitrogen deposition. Nature Geoscience 3, 315–322.
- Falloon, P. et al. (1998) Estimating the size of the inert organic matter pool. Soil Biology and Biochemistry 30, 1207–1211.
- Gale, M.R. & Grigal, D.F. (1987) Vertical root distributions of northern tree species. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 17, 829–834.
- Hassink, J. (1997) The capacity of soils to preserve organic C and N by their association with clay and silt particles. Plant and Soil 191, 77–87.
- Melillo, J.M., Aber, J.D. & Muratore, J.F. (1982) Nitrogen and lignin control of hardwood leaf litter decomposition dynamics. Ecology 63, 621–626.
- Six, J. et al. (2002) Stabilization mechanisms of soil organic matter. Plant and Soil 241, 155–176.
- Allen, R.G. et al. (1998) Crop evapotranspiration. FAO Irrigation and Drainage Paper 56. (Crop coefficients.)(作物系数。)
- NIWA climate normals, 1991–2020, for the station statistics behind the climate library.NIWA 气候标准值,1991–2020,作为气候库背后的站点统计数据。
- Hewitt, A.E. (2010) New Zealand Soil Classification, 3rd edition. Manaaki Whenua Press.
The values in the libraries are national-typical starting points assembled from these sources and from published New Zealand agronomic data. They are not measurements from your site, and the model is not a substitute for making some.
各数值库中的数值是全国典型的起点,汇编自上述来源和已发表的新西兰农学数据。它们不是来自你所在地点的测量值,而模型也不能代替你去做一些测量。